Why You Should Always Bet on Dreamers, Not Experts

Experts are generally terrible at predicting the future. If you’re an expert rolling your eyes, I offer these quotes as evidence:

“There is not the slightest possibility of such journeys.” -American astronomer F.R. Moulston on humans going to the moon (1935).

“Heavier than air ying machines are impossible.” – Lord Kelvin, President of the Royal Society of London (1895).

“The [atomic] bomb will never go off, and I speak as an expert in explosives.” -U.S. Admiral William D. Leahy to President Truman (1945).

“There is no reason for any individuals to have a computer in their home,” -Ken Olsen, founder of DEC computer company (1977).

These bold (and completely wrong) predictions, as well as many, many similar examples, prove that while experts excel at incrementally improving technology, disruptive ideas come from non-experts. Why? The more you know, the more barriers you see and the quicker you are to spot why crazy ideas won’t work. Instead, it’s dreamers like the Wright Brothers, or in contemporary times Elon Musk with his vision of taking humans to Mars, who make the great leaps in tech and business.

Thinking in Another Box

But what if you’re an expert or industry veteran rather than a newcomer full of outlandish dreams–is it hopeless that you could help create true innovation? There are lots of ideas about how to get around the problems with expertise and help experts think outside the box, but personally I believe that there is a better way to approach the limitations of experts.

Don’t try to think outside the box–you’ll only ever manage to expand it a little. Instead, think in another box.

Most people are scared about doing something in an industry with which they’re not totally familiar. ‘What do I know about X industry?’ they say to themselves. My answer is: your ignorance is what makes you the best person to disrupt that industry.

When you’re starting a new business, you don’t need to know much about it. A lot of the work is blocking and tackling–it’s the same type of stuff no matter what sector you’re in. If you don’t know much about the field, you’re able to ask a set of questions that an expert would never ask, and that allows you a very different thought process and a fresh approach.

Bringing Software Thinking to the Space Sector

Instead of trying to think outside the box in your industry, think in another box by applying your expertise to another industry. That’s what I’ve done with my latest company Moon Express. I have absolutely no idea about space exploration. I’m a software guy. But because I’m a non-expert, I’ve been able to bring the software concept of modularity into the space sector, which was never done before.

Before, if you wanted to go to the moon, experts would suggest that you build a single rocket to go all the way to the moon’s surface and come back. I looked at that plan from a software perspective and said, ‘actually, there are really three distinct modules.’

The gravity on earth is high, so you need a substantial amount of velocity and the fuel to generate it to get out of the earth’s gravity. But once you get to earth’s orbit, from there to the moon there is zero gravity, so you don’t need the same technology. You can use some type of solar sail. Finally, the gravity of the moon is one sixth of here on earth, so you can use a very small rocket.

It’s only because I have no training as a rocket scientist that I thought to ask: ‘Can you have one small rocket that takes stuff from the moon’s surface to its orbit, a separate thing that goes from moon orbit to earth orbit, and existing rockets carrying things to and from the earth’s surface, rather than one single thing?’

How to Be a Productive Non-Expert

Your business may be about as far from space travel as you can get, but the basic principle is still useful. The idea is to apply the common knowledge of one industry in another where it is completely novel.

That can mean having the courage to start a business in a niche that’s unfamiliar to you, but it doesn’t have to involve starting up in a whole new sector. The principle can be applied within existing teams too. People who are experts in one field often prefer not to talk to those with different expertise. “What does this guy know?” they think to themselves. The truth is that non-experts will ask very basic questions that will often make the experts think on a more fundamental and productive level than those with similar training.

As a leader, you can put this ability of non-experts to spur the creativity of experts to use. If you’re hosting (or attending) a lunch, for instance, never sit all the experts in similar fields together. Instead, ensure experts sit near someone who knows little about their work.That person may ask, ‘why are you doing it this way?’ An expert’s first response might be, ‘That’s stupid.’ But the second response will be, ‘but wait, that’s not a bad idea!’

Experts Have Their Uses

Of course, experts aren’t useless–far from it. After we came up with a modular approach to getting to the moon, we still needed an avionics engineer who had spent 10,000+ hours studying avionics and a propulsion engineer who just knows propulsion. Execution demands expertise, but leadership doesn’t–it demands dreams (the crazier the better).

Why are wild dreams so valuable? My mother once told me, ‘Go do what you want because the sky is the limit.’As I later learned working in the space industry there is no such physical thing as the sky–it is just a product of our imagination. Which means that, in reality, our imagination and the scale of our dreams are really the only limiting factors.

Don’t let expertise fool you into seeing false boundaries or underestimating those with wild dreams. Do that and you might end up being remembered for a spectacularly wrong prediction like the ones at the beginning of this post! Wouldn’t you rather be famous for an incredible, world-changing innovation instead? If so, bet on dreamers, not experts.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s